Is a Website Change Maintenance, a Defect, or New Work?

A broken feature, ordinary maintenance, and a new enhancement are not interchangeable purchases. The original agreement, shared components, customer impact, and acceptance tests help determine whether work is a defect correction, included upkeep, or separately scoped improvement.

By McDowell Digital Services · Updated

Compare the Request with the Agreement

A defect is behavior that does not meet the agreed requirements. An enhancement adds a feature, content, or materially different behavior beyond that scope. Maintenance addresses the agreed continuing care of the site. A single request may contain more than one kind of work.

Use the original acceptance criteria and a reproducible example to distinguish them. If an inquiry form was agreed to deliver to a particular recipient and never did, that is different from adding a CRM connection that was never included.

Scope Even a Small Addition

Identify affected pages and states, content ownership, integrations, and acceptance criteria. A short visible change can have broader implications if it changes a shared component, data collection, navigation, or payment behavior.

Preserve working customer flows and retest the affected behavior after the change. Keep a source checkpoint and recovery path appropriate to the risk. Group related changes when that reduces disruption without hiding their scope.

Choose the Appropriate Arrangement

One-time enhancements suit occasional changes. A recurring arrangement can fit genuinely continuing demand when responsibilities and capacity are agreed. Do not infer unlimited changes from the existence of a maintenance plan.

Some requests are better addressed through the owner’s CMS or platform support. Clarify the desired outcome before paying for engineering that a supported configuration already provides.

Where MDS Fits

MDS offers Ongoing Enhancements & Changes for new or materially different requests after the agreed scope. Its canonical policy states that MDS-caused defects within the agreed scope are corrected as part of the original work.

McDowell Digital Services is a United States-based remote provider. Communication is by email. The project agreement defines deliverables, dependencies, verification, and handoff. Service information explains the existing working terms.

Relevant Services and Current Pricing

These are the existing public estimates and quote paths for the listed audiences. Final pricing depends on the agreed scope, complexity, requirements, and specific needs. Project reservation deposits, where offered, are shown on the linked service pages.

Prepare a Useful Inquiry

  • The current agreement and desired change
  • Affected URLs, states, and integrations
  • Content, timing, and acceptance criteria

Send a description of the outcome you need. Do not include passwords, payment-card details, or confidential records in an initial inquiry. Discuss this project by email.